Artworld Salon

Opinion Analysis Debate

Ségolène Royal channels Barbara Kruger?

Saturday April 14, 2007 | 15:50 by Marc Spiegler in DeutscheBahn #277 | permalink

My Parisian friend CSH emailed me this: “Ségolène Royal’s “official” campaign posters, released at the beginning of this week, which are plastered on all the official posting sites next to the bureaux de votes, are complete Barbara Kruger ripoffs: Grainy black-and-white photos of “Ségo” with artsy cropping (blocking part of her much-admired forehead, for instance) sandwiched between red bars, with white block lettering on it. So ten years ago in terms of aesthetics; as for her program….” I have to agree with CSH (well, re the art; I still need to study the platforms before I vote next weekend).

Depending on how you read this, it’s either 1) a clear case of plagiarism; 2) a sign of how pervasive the Barbara Kruger aesthetic has become; or 3) a coded signifier to the ConArt crowd and feminists, reminding them that had they better rally to the cause and elect France’s first madame la presidente, even if she’s been drifting centrist to boost her electability. Sort of like when George W. Bush uses innocuous-sounding but Evangelical-derived codephrases like “wonder-working power” as semaphores of his support toward the Christian Right.

segolenekreuger.jpg

Filed Under: General
E-Mail This Post/Page del.icio.us:Ségolène Royal channels Barbara Kruger? digg:Ségolène Royal channels Barbara Kruger? Y!:Ségolène Royal channels Barbara Kruger?

3 Responses

  1. 1. András Szántó Says:

    Great find. When I first saw it in the newspapers I did a double take. Kruger is probably the most copied artist when it comes to propaganda. I do not think it is a clear case of plagiarism. And were it not France, I would not think it was an overt appeal to female voters. Then again this is France, where ideas and intellectuals still count. So maybe someone still thinks that you can appeal to voters through allusions to contemporary art.

    Which leads me to a parlor game suggestion: In thinking about the presidential campaign in this country, which artists would best suit the current candidates?


  2. 2. Marc Spiegler Says:

    Here’s some support for theory #2 from the endlessly fascinating groupblog Design Observer - the basic gist being that

    “Kruger’s work, after have been so well established for so many years, has simply become part of the atmosphere, inhaled by legions of artists, typographers, and design students everywhere, and exhaled, occasionally, as a piece of work that looks something like something Barbara Kruger would do.” … We’ve debated imitation, influence, plagiarism, homage and coincidence before, and every time, the question eventually comes up: is it possible for someone to “own” a graphic style?


  3. 3. Blog del Guerrero » Blog Archive » Interpelaciones interpelando Says:

    [...] sus apuestas, siguiendo el razonamiento de Marc Spiegler, la propaganda electoral de la candidata francesa responde [...]


Leave a Comment

If you have a username, you can login to post a comment. Please read the Comments Policy page for details.

SEARCH:


  •   
  • RECENT COMMENTS:

    SUBSCRIPTION FEEDS:

    Add to Technorati Favorites